Comparing Nutrition Tracking Apps (iOS)

I’ve decided I’m going to track nutrition again.  I tested entering the same day into 4 apps and recorded myself:

Here’s the raw video of all 4 side by side.   Its provided for reference only, I don’t expect you to actually watch it, unless you work for one of the above companies trying to understand what I saw.

4 Apps, Long and Boring

 

Here’s a close up of just the breakfast bits, for only two apps, trying to compare the same item to the same item:

2 Apps, Just Breakfast, Almost Watchable

 

Frustrations

These are all my opinions, not statements of fact. 

  • Up!
    • Could not find some restaurant food, so I had to go find something else that might or might not be equivalent.
    • Amazingly wrong values for Orange Juice (45 cal per orange!), and Orange Juice (100 cal per g)
    • While the “just add it and edit the quantity later” seems like a good idea at first, I think there were a lot more touches in the end.
      • One reason why this one had a longer video – I had to go look up caloric values for stuff it couldn’t find, so that I could go back into the app and update things to more reasonable values.  The other apps, I already knew the caloric value I was looking for, so they were spared this embarrassment.
    • Their “slider” for changing quantity took a bunch of fiddling.
    • If you enter food as you eat it, it’s a lot easier, but otherwise, selecting times for meals gets hard.  I like the other apps “Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Snack” method better. 
  • MyFitnessPal
    • Looked kinda clunky?  (but it worked!)
  • FatSecret
    • I think I was trying to put in 471g of soup, since my scale tells me its 471g, and wow that was annoying to have to scroll gently from 100 to 471.
  • Lose It!
    • Their selection of foods seemed limited, didn’t find what I was looking for.  Its like they’ve tried to reduce complexity of what is available or something?
    • App crashed during data entry, I had to restart it.

Winner

MyFitnessPal gets my “business”.  I do not remember being frustrated trying to enter anything; everything I searched for came up; they had decimal input; and I agreed with the calorie estimates given the first time around.

Tagged with: , ,
Posted in Health

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories
Tags
.net 3d 3d-printing 4k abc15 algorithms ames android anonymous types asp.net audio editing aws backup basecamp beatunes biorhythm bitcoin bittorrent blender blog boston marathon bpm c# caffeine campfire candycrush car carmax charity chiropractor cities-skylines clog clone codelouisville codepalousa coding coffee collaboration color run ComputerElbow ComputerVision configuration consulting cooking crash course crashplan crestwood cycling dabda dan dapper DataSet ddl diabetes dictation dotnetcore dotnetmud downtown e-cycling elite excel exercise expiration facebook feature-branching firefall flipflops Flow FL Studio focus food forecastle fortresscraft franklinplanner gadgets game-design games git github google docs google maps gopro gps grandpa greenshot hack half marathon headless health heart rate hiren ignew integration testing interop inventory ios ipad itunes javascript jobs karma kdf keyboards keys kittens lamont laptop lavalamp lego life lifehack linq linqtotwitter linux los angeles louisville mandelbulber massage therapy mastery-teaching maths merge metformin Minecraft miniature modeling monitor mud muhammad ali institute music mvc mycartracks netfabb nexus10 node nostalgia nutrition nwipe oldham county grand slam opal openjscad openscad owin pacedj paper mockup pepakura performance photoscan politics pomodoro postgresql powershell premiere prius process product-management project-management qa ReFS resharper review rmi roman road 5k RSI rubiks running samsung 700t sandals schedule scooter scribblelive selenium service shapeways sleep slic3r sneakersync snot software software-engineering solidoodle soylent spacegame speaking sql sqlite SSDT SSIS standing state-machine stayfocusd stonehearth sunset tablet teaching team teamcity teamtreehouse terraform tesla testing tfs time timelapse torque touch tracks trs80 Tuple tutor twitter ubuntu unit testing utilities video video editing visual studio vscode vsvim warp stabilizer windows 8 windows home server wordpress wpf xml
Archives
%d bloggers like this: