I wanted to write a nice detailed blog post with pictures and screenshots. Would take too long to get it “Perfect” so I am punting. (I did write this using the WordPress app on the phone) ** I continued this from my laptop later.
Here are crib notes instead.
Summary: it’s good, it’s functional. It’s less pretty on the watch side, and MMS is subpar, but better voice recognition, LastPass integration, wireless charging make up for that. I’m going to stick with it for a year.
Addendum: it’s frustrating to learn a new ecosystem. And because Android has so many variations it’s hard to know what information applies. For example – getting that screenshot in this post – there is probably a better way but I had to use Google voice to take it, send it to WordPress media library, then include it in this post. (Addendum to the dum: Turns out there’s a “swipe left with your palm” gesture for my phone, but I still can’t save the screenshot to my camera roll)
Stuff I like:
- Chat heads – if I use FB messenger for SMS. They pop open over any app, and let me continue a conversation without switching apps.
- Voice recognition is better – especially in the car. It seems to want to use the phone’s microphone, rather than the 3 second delay switching to bluetooth through the car microphone.
- Can choose default apps – like which Messenger app to use. Thank you “Intentions”.
- Widgets – Not going crazy with this, I only have two or three.
- Not all apps on home screen – I can leave some in the drawer. I don’t have to force myself to choose a position for EVERY FRICKING APP, just the ones that matter.
- Always on screen – specific to my Samsung S7 device? Shows time, date, next calendar appointment, etc before I hit the power button. Major phone use case.
- Number row – by default, turned on, on the keyboard. Also a swipe keyboard, very nice for one hand use.
- Better large screen shrinking – for single hand use. Much more usable than Apple’s double-finger-home-button thing that never worked for me.
- Last pass for apps – incredibly useful, when I’m in an App, Lastpass can integrate in and provide passwords.
- Wireless charging – Coworker Steve gave me his old wireless charger. I’m hooked. No plugging in. I bought one for the car, and I need to buy one for home.
- Workout app has better sharing options – Pretty pictures, square format, straight to instagram, YES.
- S2 watch can control which notifications go to watch and which dont.
- Way more watch faces – This is also a curse. I could not find a decent watch face which had battery, calendar, date, time, and actually worked across my multiple calendars.
- I can put any icon anywhere on the page – I don’t have to plan from the top. Thank God. Clusters are easier to cluster.
What I miss:
- Miss pretty emoji – I’m used to the iPhone and Slack emoji sets. I don’t know for sure when I send my wife a kiss-with-eyes-closed emoji that its showing up the same.
- Hue / OK Google integration misses things – I’ll say turn the lights off, and it will say “I got 18 of them, three not responding”, but only 8 will change.
- Miss overcast podcast player with it’s auto silence trimming – For this reason alone, I have my de-SIM’ed iPhone living in the car, being an iPod for playing podcasts.
- Group messaging wierdness interacting with iMessage – I won’t get pictures or video. My entire family is iOS based, so I’m at a disadvantage.
- Miss sharing position easily (find my friends) – Wife and I used to use this in passive always-on mode. i can do Glympse for limited engagements. I think Google has a solution for this somewhere.
- Text selection wierd no magnifying glass for fine control – it took me a while, but I finally (with writing this post) got a handle on the text select stuff. I have to take this back – I prefer the Android one. I can actually drag the little draggers around, and they snap intelligently. But I do miss the magnifying glass.
- Miss square Apple Watch – It was smaller, looked better, and seemed more functional – especially the voice command part.
- Miss scroll to top.
- S2 battery life not great. However, if I turn on Airplane mode (the S2 has its own 3G connection that I haven’t activated), its very comparable – down to 50% at the end of the day.
Btw, the screenshot is my second screen, not my home screen.
I’ve decided I’m going to track nutrition again. I tested entering the same day into 4 apps and recorded myself:
Here’s the raw video of all 4 side by side. Its provided for reference only, I don’t expect you to actually watch it, unless you work for one of the above companies trying to understand what I saw.
4 Apps, Long and Boring
Here’s a close up of just the breakfast bits, for only two apps, trying to compare the same item to the same item:
2 Apps, Just Breakfast, Almost Watchable
These are all my opinions, not statements of fact.
- Could not find some restaurant food, so I had to go find something else that might or might not be equivalent.
- Amazingly wrong values for Orange Juice (45 cal per orange!), and Orange Juice (100 cal per g)
- While the “just add it and edit the quantity later” seems like a good idea at first, I think there were a lot more touches in the end.
- One reason why this one had a longer video – I had to go look up caloric values for stuff it couldn’t find, so that I could go back into the app and update things to more reasonable values. The other apps, I already knew the caloric value I was looking for, so they were spared this embarrassment.
- Their “slider” for changing quantity took a bunch of fiddling.
- If you enter food as you eat it, it’s a lot easier, but otherwise, selecting times for meals gets hard. I like the other apps “Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Snack” method better.
- Looked kinda clunky? (but it worked!)
- I think I was trying to put in 471g of soup, since my scale tells me its 471g, and wow that was annoying to have to scroll gently from 100 to 471.
- Lose It!
- Their selection of foods seemed limited, didn’t find what I was looking for. Its like they’ve tried to reduce complexity of what is available or something?
- App crashed during data entry, I had to restart it.
MyFitnessPal gets my “business”. I do not remember being frustrated trying to enter anything; everything I searched for came up; they had decimal input; and I agreed with the calorie estimates given the first time around.
I’ve had the pleasure (and displeasure) of using both an iPad Retina and a Nexus 10 for the
last week or two last month and a half. (this post was started in the last week of December)
This year, the iPad wins.
- In Facebook, a link to a video sent me to a mobile facebook website; the Nexus crashed and rebooted. This has happened almost nightly.
- In Facebook, pictures crop too much. I couldn’t see the meme text without clicking in to the photograph.
- In Evernote, linked to a Bluetooth keyboard, trying to organize the list of stuff that I want to get done for the weekend: a total disaster.
- I could NOT use the arrow keys to navigate through the document.
- Copy and Paste did not seem to work.
- In the Trulia app: browsing real estate with the wife… Pictures much larger and UI worked better on the iPad. I was jealous that she was using the iPad and I was using the Nexus.
- Schlock Mercenary on was unusable – the UI elements fused together overlapping in a horrible way.
- Battery on the Nexus seemed to drain faster… Two days to empty instead of four. Note: This is not a measured, scientific observation.
- Watching Videos on YouTube:
- If the video started rebuffering, I could not tell the video to pause for a while (to let it get ahead). I could only pause when it was buffered and playing. On the iPad, pausing was independent of rebuffering.
- I experienced rebuffering when their appears to be data still available in the buffer.
- Netflix: About the same, till I went to make a 30-second rewind (to show my wife something awesome). On the Nexus, it did not register the shuttle change unless I did it for more than a minute. When you’re trying to show a skeptical loved one something awesome, a minute is a LONG time to wait. On the iPad, the shuttle resolution was better.
- Watching YouTube videos was a better experience – mostly due to the form factor, and better contrast. (I was watching video on both devices – letting one “buffer” up while I watched on the other)
About the same:
- Kindle Book Reading about the same on both.
- Visiting a website with Flash – without working around it on the nexus – failed equally on both. I tried working around it on the Nexus, but I couldn’t get that to work (probably the wrong browser)
- Reading email via the Gmail app was about the same on both. Both of them, I wish they fit more data on the screen.
I dearly wanted the experience to be equal.. I have a soft spot for Android, I love its “intent” system for hooking apps together.. but as an honest consumer, the iPad experience for me in December 2012, January 2013, was better. And for $100 more.. yes, I’d say it was worth it.
Addendum 2/9/2013: My wife took over the Nexus for a while. She is frustrated with it, HOWEVER, having multiple users on the device was clearly a win. She’s going to get an iPad Mini, it fits her collection of purses better. (Women are weird) (I like them like that)